you just met new girls in their bedrooms? sounds questionable
Plot twist: you should look at your tiny pink asshole instead my friend coz that beast is there to get you not your gal
And which of the 2 attracted you more that you decided to spend the night with?
Fisting is the way
Shes a keeper
"Hold on little buddy - you can do it. Dont be affraid!"
Use the toy on her while filling the mouth with yours. NP ¯\_(ツ)_/¯